
When leaders expect employees to be happy, they may discourage the honesty needed to build trust.
I have a zero-drama policy at Luma Brighter Learning. Some people might assume that means I expect employees to rate their happiness at work as a 10/10, avoid disagreements, and support every leadership decision. That could not be further from my intentions.
Authenticity has been my research focus since my doctoral degree. From a learning perspective, authenticity means creating environments with relevance or real-world applications for the learners. My recent research on happiness in the workplace prompted me to consider how authenticity influences employee engagement.
The foundation of a healthy workplace should be built on open communication and trust. Employees should not feel a constant pressure to maintain a positive attitude or rate their happiness as a 10 when there are legitimate concerns or frustrations. Research shows why this matters. A 2025 meta-analysis of 27 studies, for example, found that surface acting was significantly associated with depression and anxiety in the workplace. With surface acting, employees display emotions they do not genuinely feel to meet organizational expectations. Workplace toxic positivity can surface when employees feel pressured to display happiness or optimism regardless of how they truly feel.
Surface acting is not inherently toxic. At times, professionalism requires us to manage our emotions. Workplace toxicity arises when employees consistently feel obligated to suppress genuine emotions to meet organizational expectations. When we ask employees to rate their happiness, the goal should not be to appease leadership. The goal should always be to find ways to improve their workplace happiness.
At Luma Brighter Learning, zero drama also does not mean zero grace, feedback, or honesty. Our policy discourages gossip, assumptions, and behaviors that undermine teamwork. It also encourages employees to communicate directly, acknowledge mistakes, and treat one another with kindness.
Make authenticity visible
Here are three ways leaders can make authenticity visible in their organizations.
1. Encourage direct feedback
All employees and leaders should feel comfortable having difficult conversations. When misunderstandings arise, we encourage direct communication rather than conversations behind someone’s back. Sometimes, employees need coaching to navigate these discussions. Leaders can help facilitate conversations that allow people to explain their perspectives and better understand one another.
We can agree to disagree. I believe people generally come to work with good intentions, even when their actions or communication fall short.
2. Address gossip without discouraging honest concerns
Gossip can damage relationships and create unnecessary division. Teamwork is one of our five core values. We expect leaders and employees to display teamwork through their actions. For example, if an employee says, “don’t tell anyone but…” it most likely is a sign of gossiping. Employees and leaders have a duty to stop these conversations in their tracks.
There is an important difference between harmful gossip and raising legitimate workplace concerns. Employees must feel safe discussing problems, reporting inappropriate behavior, and questioning decisions. Our expectation is that employees address concerns constructively rather than criticize coworkers or make assumptions about their intentions. Kindness and accountability can coexist.
3. Hold everyone to the same standard of integrity
Integrity is another of our core values. Every team member, including leaders, is held to this standard.This means being honest even during challenging times, being open to difficult feedback from your employees, and making it feel safe to have difficult conversations. Employees bring experiences from previous workplaces that influence whether they feel comfortable speaking openly. It is not surprising these are new skills for most employees.
Leaders must earn that trust through consistent behavior.
Final thoughts
A zero-drama culture cannot exist without honesty, consistency, and trust. Workplace hypocrisy begins when leaders expect employees to uphold standards they do not follow themselves.
For me, our workplace happiness scale is an opportunity to invite honest conversations grounded in authenticity. Our goal is not to create a workplace where everyone appears happy. It is to create an environment where employees feel safe enough to be honest about what would help them thrive.
Article originally published on November 3, 2026 on INC Magazine.
